Source: Mediashift.com |
Morel is a former AP photographer, who was in Haiti
during earthquake in January, 2010. In less than two hours, Live images of the
destruction from the earthquake were posted on his Twitpic account. The
photographs on the account were taken and re-tweeted under another user name in
Twitter. AFP took and save those photographs and distributed them under the
false credit through its own image service and Getty. They have continued doing
it although they knew that the photographs were belong to Morel, and no
permission was approved. (Walker 2012). Therefore, Morel engaged The Hoffman
Law Firm to send Cease and desist letters to both AFP,
their distributor as well as the two companies' clients and subscribers after he realised his work was being distributed without
permission (Nicholl 2010).
AFP argued that twitter allowed it to distribute the
photos without permission and distribute them through Getty images. Meanwhile,
twitter TOS provides users to hold their rights to the content that they
published.
In my opinion, as a credible magazine company, they
should find out who is the owner of the picture instead of making conclusion
that the picture they found belongs to the owner as stealing pictures and
credit are common in internet. Meanwhile, Morel should have included his name
on the picture as a credit and this will reduce the problem of stealing
credits. Besides that, i think Morel should sue Suraero as he was the one who
stole his pictures and credits.
After his issue, many infuential twitter users started to
boycott. Sean Garrett (@sg), part of the Twitter communications team tweeted that
“you own your tweets and photos will be part of your tweets,” to a user
concerned about ownership (media bistro).
Hence, the photos available
online should be belong to the original owner and to use the photos, permission
should be granted. Stealing other people's pictures are like stealing people's
ideas as known as plagiarizing (Bailey
2013).
References
Bailey, J 2013, The
Challenge Faced By Photographers, Plagirism Today, viewed 2nd June 2013,
<http://www.plagiarismtoday.com/2013/01/16/the-challenge-faced-by-photographers/>
Nicholl, J 2010, We Stole
Your Pictures, Now We're Going to Sue You, The Russians Photos Blog, viewed
2nd June 2013, <http://www.jeremynicholl.com/blog/2010/05/03/afp-steal-photos-then-sue-photographer-2/>
Walker, D 2012, Morel Releases More Evidence
Against AFP, Getty in Copyright Case, PonPulse, viewed 2nd June 2012,
<http://pdnpulse.com/2012/05/morel-releases-more-evidence-against-afp-getty-in-copyright-case.html>
No comments:
Post a Comment